Fort Myers is one of the best places in Florida to own a boat. With the Caloosahatchee River, the Gulf of Mexico, and countless waterways within easy reach, boating is a way of life here. But every time you take your boat out, you’re exposed to risks that your regular homeowners or auto policy won’t cover. Choosing the right boat insurance in Fort Myers starts with understanding what’s available and what you actually need.
At Bassine Insurance Agency, we help Fort Myers boat owners find policies that match their vessel, their boating habits, and their budget. Whether you own a fishing boat, a pontoon, or a cabin cruiser, here’s what to look for when shopping for boat insurance.
Types of Boat Insurance Coverage

Boat insurance policies can be customized to fit your specific situation. Here are the main types of coverage you should consider.
- Hull coverage protects the physical structure of your boat against damage from collisions, storms, fire, theft, and vandalism. This is the core of your policy and can be written on either an agreed value or actual cash value basis.
- Liability coverage pays for injuries or property damage you cause to others while operating your boat. If you collide with another vessel or a passenger on your boat is injured, liability coverage handles the costs.
- Medical payments coverage pays for medical expenses for you and your passengers regardless of who’s at fault. This is especially important since boating accidents can result in serious injuries.
- Uninsured boater coverage protects you if you’re hit by another boater who doesn’t have insurance. Just like on the road, not every boat operator carries adequate coverage.
- Towing and assistance coverage pays for on-water towing, fuel delivery, and other emergency services. Getting towed back to a Fort Myers marina can cost hundreds of dollars without this coverage.
We recommend starting with hull and liability coverage as your foundation, then adding medical payments, uninsured boater, and towing coverage based on how and where you use your boat.
Agreed Value vs Actual Cash Value
One of the most important decisions in boat insurance is how your vessel will be valued if it’s totaled or stolen. There are two main approaches.
- Agreed value means you and the insurance company agree on your boat’s value when the policy is written. If your boat is totaled, you receive that full agreed amount with no depreciation deducted.
- Actual cash value means the insurance company pays what your boat is worth at the time of the loss, after accounting for depreciation. This usually results in a lower payout than agreed value.
For most Fort Myers boat owners, we recommend agreed value coverage. Boats are significant investments, and knowing exactly what you’ll receive in a total loss gives you the certainty you need to replace your vessel without financial strain.
What Affects Your Boat Insurance Premium

Several factors influence how much you’ll pay for boat insurance in Fort Myers.
- The type, size, and value of your boat. Larger, more powerful boats cost more to insure.
- Where you store your boat. A boat kept in a covered marina or on a lift is less risky than one left on a trailer in your driveway.
- Your boating experience and any safety courses you’ve completed. Many carriers offer discounts for completing boating safety courses.
- Your claims history. A clean record with no prior claims will earn you better rates.
- The navigation area. Policies that restrict your boating to inland waters may cost less than those covering open Gulf waters.
We compare rates from multiple boat insurance carriers to find the best combination of coverage and price for your situation.
Hurricane Season and Boat Insurance
Living in Fort Myers means hurricane season is always on the calendar from June through November. Your boat insurance policy should address storm-related risks specifically.
- Most policies require you to follow a hurricane haul-out plan. If a named storm approaches, you may need to haul your boat out of the water and store it safely within a specified timeframe.
- Some policies have separate named storm deductibles that are higher than the standard deductible.
- Comprehensive coverage typically includes hurricane wind damage, but make sure your policy doesn’t exclude storm surge or flood damage to the vessel.
Having a clear plan for your boat during hurricane season is essential, and your insurance policy should support that plan. We help clients review their hurricane requirements before the season starts so there are no surprises.
For more information, you may find these resources helpful: Florida Fish and Wildlife boating regulations and U.S. Coast Guard Boating Safety.
Frequently Asked Questions

Is boat insurance required in Florida?
Florida does not legally require boat insurance for recreational vessels. However, if you have a loan or finance your boat, your lender will require it. Even without a loan, carrying boat insurance is strongly recommended given the risks of boating in Fort Myers waters.
How much does boat insurance cost in Fort Myers?
Annual premiums typically range from $300 to $1,500 or more depending on your boat’s value, type, and how you use it. Fishing boats and pontoons are generally less expensive to insure than high-performance or offshore vessels.
Does boat insurance cover fishing equipment?
Many policies include coverage for personal effects and fishing equipment stored on the boat, but there are usually limits. If you carry expensive electronics, tackle, or gear, ask about increasing your personal effects coverage.
What should I do with my boat during a hurricane?
Follow your policy’s hurricane haul-out requirements, which typically involve securing your boat on land well before a storm arrives. Failing to follow your policy’s hurricane plan could result in a denied claim.
Your boat is an investment and a source of enjoyment. Protecting it with the right insurance means you can spend more time on the water and less time worrying. Call Bassine Insurance Agency at (239) 995-0333 or request a quote to explore your boat insurance options in Fort Myers.























